Aluminum water bottle vs stainless steel

We use water bottles every day. It is important to choose a good quality, safe, and competitive water bottle. You can see many plastic water bottles, and aluminum and stainless steel water bottles in the market. Among these, Aluminum and stainless steel are the most reliable choices for drinking bottles. Plastic water bottles aren’t exactly great for the environment. Aluminum and stainless steel water bottles are totally recyclable. This is the reason why more and more people are using Aluminum and stainless steel water bottles.

But maybe we are also thinking of aluminum or stainless steel water bottles, which one is better? Should we use aluminum water bottle or stainless steel water bottle? Want to check more details on aluminum water bottles vs stainless steel water bottles, please keep reading.

ALUMINUM WATER BOTTLES

Aluminum is a popular material for drinking containers. The aluminum water bottles are crafted out of food-grade and BPA-free aluminum materials. It is durable and rust-resistant, and they are much better than plastic bottles because they are totally 100% recyclable. Considering the world is crowded with too much plastic, aluminum water bottles are really green packaging to protect the environment. What’s more, they are so light to carry everywhere, which makes them good for sports, such as bike, hiking, trekking, camping, climbing, and so on. Aluminum water bottles are reusable water bottles, they can be reused as many times as you want.

Aluminum is an excellent conductor of heat, making it ideal for use in insulated water bottles. Aluminum water bottles are also recyclable, making them a more sustainable choice than plastic bottles. You can see aluminum cans for juice and beer in our everyday life, aluminum cups are also more and more welcomed.

Because aluminum reacts with certain liquids, aluminum bottles are lined–typically with enamel, resin, polymer, or epoxy. Most factories will not disclose liner materials, citing confidentiality, but will test and affirm BPA-free, food-grade liners.  Aluminum water bottles are not dishwasher safe.

Stainless Steel Water Bottle

Stainless steel bottles are generally crafted from food-grade stainless steel. Since stainless steel is non-reactive, bottles made from this material don’t leach and don’t have to be lined. Since stainless steel contains nickel, people with allergies to this metal should avoid stainless steel water bottles.

Stainless steel drinking bottles often use 18/8 material, consisting of 18% chromium and 8% nickel. This composition enables stainless steel bottles to resist high temperatures, improve weldability, and prevent corrosion. Stainless steel drinking bottles are more durable but heavier than aluminum water bottles. They are good for keeping the drinking water or juice warm and cold.

ALUMINUM WATER BOTTLE VS STAINLESS STEEL

Both aluminum and stainless steel water bottles are good for drinking. There are many differences and similarities between aluminum and stainless steel water bottles. But it’s hard to say which one is better, it depends on the demands or requirements that you need. Please check below for more details.

Material:

In terms of material comparison, stainless steel water bottles are generally heavier but more durable, while aluminum water bottles are lighter and cooler to the touch. Stainless steel bottles are also considered safer for drinking water as they do not leach chemicals. However, aluminum bottles offer more variety in terms of shapes and colors and are typically less expensive.

Durability:

Unlike glass or plastic bottles, stainless steel and aluminum drinking bottles are more likely to withstand cracks or breakage. Stainless steel contains Mo, Ni, Cr, Mn these elements which can increase it’s hardness. Stainless steel can better endure daily wear and tear, yet aluminum bottles can also boast long-term durability. Generally, stainless steel bottles are more durable than aluminum bottles, but aluminum bottles are more durable than plastic bottles.

Insulation:

Insulation refers to the ability of a material to prevent the transfer of heat or cold. In the context of water bottles, insulation means that the material can keep the temperature of the liquid inside the bottle relatively constant, either by keeping it hot or cold for longer periods of time.

Both aluminum and stainless steel water bottles can offer insulation to keep your drinks colder for longer periods of time. However, stainless steel bottles tend to be more effective at maintaining temperature due to their higher density and thicker walls.

Safety:

Stainless steel bottles are generally crafted from food-grade stainless steel. Since stainless steel is non-reactive, bottles made from this material don’t leach and don’t have to be lined. Unfortunately, due to the metal content in the bottle (iron, zinc, and copper), stainless steel water bottles tend to impart a metallic taste to the water they contain. After several washes, this usually goes away, but it always depends on the kind of customized stainless steel water bottle.

Aluminum reacts with certain liquids, aluminum bottles are lined–typically with an enamel, resin, polymer, or epoxy. Most factories will not disclose liner materials, citing confidentiality, but will test and affirm BPA-free, food-grade liners. 

Costs:

Most articles don’t mention it. Generally, stainless steel water bottles are far more expensive than aluminum water bottles. The raw materials of stainless steel 304 or 316 are more expensive than aluminum raw materials. Another important reason is that stainless steel density is 7.93 g/cm³ but aluminum density is 2.7 g/cm³. It means if you buy the same size bottle, stainless steel will cost treble material cost than aluminum. Generally, stainless steel water bottles will be three times or even more expensive than aluminum water bottles. Also, disposable aluminum water bottles are much cheaper than normal aluminum water bottles.

Portability:

Most aluminum and stainless steel drinking bottles come in various sizes and capacities. These factors make them ideal for drinking water, whether on a hike or working at home. Likewise, they don’t take up much space or add considerable weight.

Appearance:

Stainless steel and aluminum bottles have sleek and stylish appearances. You can choose colors or even customize the design. Comparing the two containers, aluminum bottles are considered more stylish than stainless steel bottles. With the growing trend and ubiquity of these good-looking aluminum bottles, choosing aluminum as your next container can allow you to stay stylish with every sip of your drink. On the other hand, stainless steel water bottles are generally more plain-looking but often customizable by colors that come in metallic and gradient shades.

RECYCLABILITY:

The good thing is that stainless steel and aluminum are among the most recyclable materials on earth. It’s relatively easy to clean bottles, as well as remove mold or disinfect them. Even if they don’t end up in processing plants, you can repurpose the bottles into everyday items in your home.

Rust-resistance:

Aluminum forms a thin layer of aluminum oxide when exposed to air, preventing the development of rust. Similarly, stainless steel creates a thin, stable film when chromium reacts with the surrounding oxygen.

Rust-resistance:

Aluminum water bottles have a lower carbon footprint due to their lighter weight and easier recycling, but may have health concerns related to aluminum exposure. Stainless steel water bottles are more durable and have no health concerns, but are heavier and require more energy to produce. Both can be sustainable choices depending on individual priorities and proper use and disposal.

Comparison sheet

Aluminum water bottleStainless steel water bottle
DurabilityDurableCrack resistant
SafetySafeSafe
CostsCheaperExpensive
WeightLightweightHeavier
RecyclabilityRecyclableRecyclable
ReusableReusableReusable
PortabilityPortablePortable
AppearanceMore sleek and stylishsleek and stylish
Rust-resistance:Rust-resistanceRust-resistance
Dishwasher safeNoYes
REACTIVITYreactive to certain liquidnon-reactive
BPA-FREEYes, BPA-FREEYes, BPA-FREE
InsulationCan hold cold and hot drinks short timeCan hold cold and hot drinks for 24 hours
CustomizableYesYes
Metallic tasteNoYes, may have a metallic taste
SustainabilityYesYes

Do aluminum water bottles keep drinks cold

Aluminum water bottles do keep drinks cold. We can see that aluminum water bottles are the best for keeping drinks cold, compared with stainless steel bottles, and plastic bottles.

The aluminum material helps to temperature control your beverages. Aluminum has a higher heat transfer rate than iron and stainless steel which is why it’s common to use aluminum water bottles for drinking. As a result, aluminum water bottles are suitable for cold drink containers, such as water, beer, and beverages. Aluminum water bottles could keep drinks colder.

The thermal conductivity of aluminum is around 205-250 W/(m⋅K) , stainless steel ranges from 14-19 W/(m⋅K), and glass is about 1.0-1.4 W/(m⋅K) , while plastic only 0.1-0.5 W/(m⋅K). The data showed aluminum heat transfer is the best. Source from The Engineering ToolBox.

Aluminum water bottles

How to tell if the water bottle is stainless steel or aluminum

Aluminum water bottles look quite similar to stainless steel water bottles, but there are always ways to differentiate them.

  • The stainless steel water bottle will be much heavier than the aluminum one. That is because the density of stainless steel is 7.8 gm/cc against that of aluminum 2.7 gm/cc.
  • If you have access to an eddy current tester, you can differentiate between the two because their electrical conductivities are markedly different. Aluminum has very high conductivity compared to stainless steel.
  • Surface hardness. The surface of stainless steel is harder than that of aluminum alloy. Stainless steel is not easily scratched by a hard object.
  • Tap test: You can tap the bottle with your fingernail or a metal object. Stainless steel tends to produce a higher-pitched sound compared to aluminum, which produces a duller sound.
  • Insulation: Generally the insulation water bottles are made of stainless steel. Aluminum water bottles are single wall, so they can not keep water/juice hot inside.

A Guide to the Best Water Bottle

It is important to choose the best water bottles in life because we need to drink enough water every day. That means the water bottle is the most frequently used bottle in our lives. There are many factors that will influence the water bottles. Below we tried to introduce with details to help people choose the best water bottle.

  • Safety: the first you need to consider is if it is safe for drinking. You need to avoid water bottles from BPA, which means you need to choose BPA-free bottles. Don’t trust these plastic water bottles which may contain BPA inside.
  • Styles / Color Options: This is the start that you need to consider. Some water bottles were built for mobility, while others are better suited for tabletop use. (Or the floor of a tent.) The best water bottles have lots of color options to choose from, so if you’re looking for a gym accessory to match your personal style, you’re bound to find something you like among the slimmer models. 
  • Size and Liquid Capacity: Smaller water bottles might only hold 10 ounces liquid (or less), which is great if you plan on taking yours on daily jogs. Others are built like tanks and are great for hardcore camping expeditions. Or maybe you’re just looking for a water bottle to keep by your desk while you work. Think about how you plan to use the water bottle before settling on a size. 
  •  Mouth and cap style: if you want to add some ice or powder mixes into a water bottle, then you have to choose a wide-mouth water bottle. There are many caps to suit different mouths of water bottles. You need to choose that kind of cap with no leakage, safe and easy to open and off.
  • Costs: after you have considered above these elements, you need to think about your budget. If you choose a stainless steel bottle, then the price is more expensive than aluminum water bottle. A insulated water bottle is more expensive than a single wall water bottle. So you need to consider your budget carefully.
  • Insulation: Generally the insulation water bottles are made of stainless steel. Insulation water bottles can keep the water cold or hot for a long time. If you want to use the water bottle that keeps the water inside warm/cold, then you have to consider the insulation water bottles. But normally insulation water bottles are also in a higher price.

Conclusion:

In conclusion, both aluminum and stainless steel water bottles have their advantages and disadvantages. You can choose the most suitable water bottles according to your requirements. If you want to use water bottles for hiking, camping, sports, or bicycling, then aluminum water bottles should be your best choice. If you want to use a good quality bottle for drinking hot or cold water in the home or office, then maybe a stainless steel water bottle is your best choice.

 Anyhow, please also consider your budget. Try to buy these water bottles from a large brand or original manufacturer. Try to not use plastic water bottles because they are not recyclable. We need to consider the recyclable of water bottles and do something better for our environment.

FAQ:

Stainless steel water bottles are not toxic to humans because they are BPA-free, plastic-free, and phthalate-free. High-quality stainless steels are the safest water bottles to drink from. When it comes to reusable water bottles, it is better than plastic and aluminum bottles.

The acidity of lemons may be too much for aluminum bottles, but what about stainless steel? While there’s no need to worry about the lemon causing rust or corrosion, there’s always been a myth that lemon can change the flavor of stainless steel and discolor it.

While the color of the bottle’s interior will not change, the flavor of your beverage might be a little different. Then again, if you’re adding lemon to your stainless steel water bottle, it’s to augment the flavor.

You can absolutely add lemon to a stainless steel water bottle, then. Just make sure the bottle is indeed stainless steel and not aluminum. Lemon could damage aluminum bottles in a hurry!

Yes, aluminum water bottles are safe for everyday use. They are often lined with a food-grade coating to prevent any interaction between the aluminum and the water. The National Institutes of Health (NIH) states that the use of aluminum bottles for water storage is safe and does not pose a health risk. 

Aluminum water bottles have a lower environmental impact than stainless steel bottles. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) reports that aluminum recycling saves 95% of the energy required to produce new aluminum from raw materials, leading to reduced greenhouse gas emissions. This makes aluminum water bottles a more sustainable choice. 

Aluminum water bottles are more cost-effective in the long run due to their lower production and recycling energy requirements. A study conducted by the University of California, Berkeley, found that over a 10-year period, the total cost of ownership for aluminum water bottles was significantly lower than that of stainless steel bottles, making them a more economical choice. 

Both aluminum and stainless steel water bottles are designed to maintain the taste of water without any metallic flavor. The World Health Organization (WHO) states that properly coated aluminum and stainless steel water bottles do not affect the taste, odor, or color of water, ensuring a pleasant drinking experience.

This applies to aluminum water bottles, too. The CDC states that aluminum is not harmful, making it a good alternative to even BPA-free plastic water bottles, and especially so against plastic water bottles that have BPA. Along with being a generally safe material, aluminum is hygienic.

Related products: